Felicia Wagner, SHRM-CP, MHRM
Senior Recruiter @ Portfolio Creative
About
Creative matchmaker. Strategic recruiter. Storyteller at heart. I’m a senior recruiter specializing in marketing, creative, and digital talent, with a background in boutique staffing and full-cycle recruiting. I connect standout people with roles where they can thrive — and help clients build strong, effective teams through a people-first, high-touch approach. I care deeply about the work that actually moves the needle: building trust, offering thoughtful guidance, and finding those “just right” fits. My results are rooted in emotional intelligence, clear communication, and a genuine investment in both candidate experience and client partnership. Whether I’m coaching someone through a pivotal career move, refining a job description, or solving a complex staffing challenge, I bring sharp instincts, warmth, and a bias toward action. I believe recruiting should feel intentional and human — not transactional. Outside of work, you’ll usually find me watching a stellar TV show, listening to an engaging podcast, or spending time with my adoring family. Let’s connect — whether you’re hiring, job hunting, or just want to trade thoughts on the current job market. 💪 Gallup CliftonStrengths 🤝 Connectedness | 🦄 Individualization | 🫀 Empathy | 👷🏻♀️ Developer | 🛠 Restorative 🚨 I value thoughtful, personalized outreach. If you’re reaching out to connect, a tailored message goes a long way. 🚨
United States
Columbus
Staffing & Recruiting
Full Life Cycle Recruiting, Candidate Selection, Screening Resumes, Passive Candidate Generation, Qualifying Candidates, Candidate Retention, Business Development, Bullhorn, Job Description Development, Stakeholder Management, Stakeholder Engagement, Strategic Recruitment Planning, Employer Branding, Workforce Planning, Workforce Development, Contingent Workforce, Rate Negotiation, Market Mapping, Contract Recruitment, Direct-hire
Experience

Senior Recruiter
Columbus, Ohio Metropolitan Area
Promoted through multiple roles (Lead Recruiter → Recruiting Manager → Senior Recruiter) based on performance and evolving business needs. Currently own full-cycle recruiting responsibilities for the agency’s marketing and creative desk. • Deliver strong recruiting outcomes in a boutique marketing and creative staffing environment, supporting contract, contract-to-hire, and direct hire placements • In peak-year performance, supported $700K+ in annualized revenue and managed ~10,000 billable consultant hours across active client engagements • Partner closely with leadership and clients on hiring strategy, role scoping, and market insights • Own full-cycle recruiting end-to-end, including sourcing, screening, stakeholder partnership, and candidate experience • Drive recruiting KPIs, pipeline health, and delivery across multiple concurrent engagements • Lead candidate offer discussions and support compensation alignment between clients and candidates • Balance recruiting delivery, operational execution, and client partnership responsibilities in a lean environment • Reduced prescreening time by 50% through intake redesign and process improvements • Built and maintained a 15K+ candidate network leveraging LinkedIn Recruiter, Indeed, OhioMeansJobs, Dice, and referrals

Talent Sourcing Specialist
Columbus, OH, United States
• Managed inbound candidate interest and scheduled prescreening interviews to assess fit for active and future opportunities. • Helped accelerate time-to-fill by effectively qualifying candidates for future roles.

Store Operations Leader
Columbus, Ohio, United States
• Opened a new storefront and hired, trained, and onboarded an entirely new team • Maintained day-to-day store operations including schedule-writing, managing inventory, employee training and development, and setting and accomplishing sales goals

Business Consultant (Short-Term Project)
Columbus, Ohio Area
Part of the Leadership Effectiveness through Applied Projects & Coaching (LEAP+C) program at OSU • Worked with a team of MBA and MHRM students to provide targeted business consulting to Glass Axis, a local nonprofit that serves local glass artists and community members who want to learn about and participate in glass art creation • Projected scope encompassed utilizing a particular space within the facility to drive new customers and revenue and fulfill the mission of the organization with the potential to partner with other local vendors

Career Counselor - Specialized Degrees
Columbus, Ohio Area
• Coached students pursuing specialized business degrees in the form of resume reviews, career planning, and interview preparation • Planned and executed OCM (Office of Career Management) events such as annual career fairs, orientations, guest speakers, and workshops

Executive Talent Acquisition Consultant (Short-Term Project)
Remote
• Engaged and screened alumni and other qualified professionals to be matched with 27 open Executive Director positions in North America • Consulted with local campus staff in developing strategic hiring, compensation, and management plans for new Executive Directors

Talent Acquisition Coordinator (Internship)
Columbus, Ohio
• Sourced and pre-screened 25 candidates for the ALPFA conference resulting in 3 anticipatory offers,1 FTE offer, and 8 internships as well as engaged 140 NASP Conference attendees to increase their probability of connecting with a Nationwide representative at the conference • Conducted a complete audit of the HRIS system to mitigate potential legal risks and maintain an exceptional candidate experience • Spearheaded various strategic activities such as developing pre- and post- conference recruitment plans, hosting HR Community lunches, and creating a compensation matrix resource to assist HR business partners in the calibration of a newly created position • Designed a list of local associations and a calendar of events focused on Nationwide's core business units and diversity initiatives to assist the Talent Acquisition team in identifying untapped talent pools • Proactively initiated more than 50 one-on-one networking and discovery opportunities with associates and leaders • Organized and managed a team of 4 software developers to create an innovative on-boarding text messaging program for the annual Nationwide Hackathon • Received a month-long internship extension due to exceptional performance at the request of the AVP

Director of Engagement and Programming - OSU Hillel: Wexner Jewish Student Center
46 E 16th Ave Columbus, OH 43201
In addition to continued responsibilities of Engagement Associate: SUPERVISION • Supervised Program Associate position and more than fifteen student interns EDUCATION • Educated students about Jewish holidays and their observance • Managed weekly observance of Shabbat including boosting staff morale with a pre-Shabbat gathering, supervising two ritual life interns, and managing all logistics of religious services and dinner every Friday evening INNOVATION • Rebuilt organizational website and newsletter with the assistance of an innovative student marketing team structure under my supervision DEVELOPMENT • Raised more than $100,000 in grants and fundraising over 4 years LEADERSHIP • Mentored entry-level professionals from Hillels around the world and facilitated the field-created and field-run Hillel Mentorship Initiative since 2013 which matches mid-level professional mentors with entry-level professionals who communicate monthly one-on-one and on a group call • Designed and distributed direct mailings, created case statements, and participated in a bi-monthly conference call with Hillel International Development staff as part of the first ever Hillel International Jewish Philanthropy Seminar • Assisted supervisor in consulting other campuses in hiring top-management employees and grant-writing CONTINUED EDUCATION: • Participated in BCI (Brandeis Collegiate Institute) in Simi Valley, CA during the summer of 2015 • Attended Pardes Institute of Jewish Education in Jerusalem, Israel during the summer of 2014 • Hillel Institute and Hillel International Global Assembly yearly since 2012 • Staffed two Taglit-Birthright Israel: OSU Hillel trips and a community high school trip called Partners Together

Engagement Associate - OSU Hillel: Wexner Jewish Student Center
46 E 16th Ave. Columbus, OH 43201
ENGAGEMENT AND PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT • Engaged unaffiliated students in Jewish life at The Ohio State University and tracked engagements in organizational database • Supervised more than 4 student organizations and their leaders and assisted in developing meaningful programming COALITION BUILDING • Built coalitions with other organizations on campus and within the community to create diverse programming RECRUITMENT • Promoted OSU Hillel to incoming students through email and social media outreach, phone calls, and building tours • Organized and conducted talent searches and interviews for new employees
Felicia Wagner, SHRM-CP, MHRM's Contact Information
Phone
Find the Right Leads
Find Verified Contact Data
What LeadContact does well
Find verified emails, phone numbers, and decision-makers with 98% accuracy.
Find Leads
Find the right people by company, role, industry, location, and more.
925M+ professional profiles

Find Emails
Access verified email addresses for your target contacts.
657M+ emails

Find Phone Numbers
Get cross-validated phone data from multiple top sources.
239M+ phone numbers

More Accurate. Lower Cost.
Find contact data in 1 tool with 98% accuracy
LeadContact integrates leading enrichment tools to deliver more accurate contact data—without paying for each one.
Great conversations start with the right contact.
It’s time to find yours.




